The 5 Most Common Website Mistakes Small Business Owners Make (and How to Fix Them)

Madison Mohn • 18 October 2024

A computer , laptop , tablet , and phone displaying a website on a white background.

A well-designed, functional website is crucial for small business owners aiming to thrive in a competitive market. Unfortunately, many make mistakes that hinder their website's effectiveness, resulting in missed opportunities for growth and visibility. Here, we'll explore the five most common website mistakes small business owners make and provide practical solutions to fix them.

Free Website Audit

Avoid These Common Website Mistakes to Maximize Success

From poor user experience to missed SEO opportunities, these errors can deter visitors and reduce conversion rates. This guide highlights the five most common website mistakes and provides actionable tips to fix them, making your website a powerful growth tool.

A drawing of a number one in a circle on a white background.

Poor Website Navigation

The Mistake:
Many small business websites suffer from confusing or poorly organized navigation. This makes it hard for visitors to find what they need, leading to frustration and potential loss of customers. Complicated menus, broken links, or a lack of clear calls to action (CTAs) are common issues.

The Fix:
Focus on creating a clean, intuitive navigation structure. Organize your content into clear categories, and ensure that your primary menu includes essential pages such as Home, Services, About Us, Contact, and Blog. Avoid using too many submenus or pages, and make sure all links are functional. Testing your navigation on mobile devices is also critical, as more users browse on phones. You can read more here!

The number 2 is written in a circle on a white background.

Lack of Mobile Optimization

The Mistake:
With over half of all website traffic coming from mobile devices, not optimizing for mobile is a critical mistake. If your website doesn’t display properly on smartphones and tablets, you risk losing a significant number of visitors.

The Fix:
Adopt a responsive web design that automatically adjusts the layout and elements of your website based on the device being used. Regularly test your website on various mobile devices to ensure everything works seamlessly, including navigation, images, and forms. Using Google's Mobile-Friendly Test tool is a great way to check if your site meets mobile optimization standards.

The number three is written in a circle on a white background.

Slow Page Load Times

The Mistake:
Page speed is a critical factor for both user experience and SEO. If your website takes too long to load, users will abandon it, and search engines will penalize your ranking. Slow load times can result from large images, excessive plugins, or poor-quality hosting.

The Fix:
Optimize images by compressing them without losing quality, minimize the use of heavy scripts and unnecessary plugins, and choose a reliable web hosting service with fast load times. There are tools that can help you identify issues affecting your website’s speed and provide suggestions for improvement.

The number four is written in a circle on a white background.

Weak SEO Implementation

The Mistake:
Many small businesses overlook SEO, leading to poor search engine rankings. Without proper keyword optimization, relevant meta tags, or a clear content strategy, your website may be invisible to potential customers searching for your services online.

The Fix:
Start by conducting keyword research to find terms your target audience is searching for, and incorporate these keywords naturally into your content, headers, and meta descriptions. Ensure each page has a unique title tag and meta description, and implement an ongoing SEO strategy that includes updating your blog with fresh, relevant content. Utilizing tools like Google Search Console can help track your SEO progress and identify areas for improvement.

The number five is in a circle on a white background.

No Clear Call to Action (CTA)

The Mistake:
Visitors to your site need guidance on what to do next, whether it's making a purchase, signing up for a newsletter, or contacting you for more information. Websites that lack clear CTAs miss out on converting visitors into customers.

The Fix:
Ensure that each page has a clear, visible CTA that aligns with your business goals. Use action-oriented language like “Sign Up Now,” “Get a Free Quote,” or “Contact Us Today.” Place CTAs in strategic locations such as at the end of blog posts, on the homepage, and near product or service descriptions. Testing different CTA designs and placements using tools like A/B testing can help optimize their effectiveness.

Optimize Your Small Business Website for Growth

Small business websites are powerful tools that can drive growth, but only when designed and managed effectively. By addressing these common mistakes—improving navigation, optimizing for mobile, boosting page speed, refining SEO, and using clear CTAs—you can enhance user experience, improve search rankings, and ultimately increase conversions.


If you need further assistance in optimizing your website, reach out to us for a free consultation.

Schedule a Consultation
A woman is sitting at a table using a laptop computer.
by Madison Mohn 15 January 2025
Building an accessible website ensures everyone can engage with your content, regardless of their abilities. From optimizing color contrast to adding accessibility plugins, small steps make a big impact. Prioritize inclusivity and show your audience you care! Need help creating an accessible website? Reach out to us today, and let’s make the web a welcoming space for all.
A man and a woman are sitting at a table looking at a laptop.
by Madison Mohn 4 November 2024
Ranking higher on local search results can make all the difference for small businesses. Local SEO helps you show up in searches specific to your area, bringing in more nearby customers. In this guide, discover essential steps like claiming your Google My Business listing, using local keywords, adding your business to local directories, and building local backlinks. Whether you’re a bakery or a handyman, these tips can boost your visibility and help you connect with your community. Dive into the basics of Local SEO and start showing up right where your customers are looking!
Two women are looking out of a window at a plant.
by Madison Mohn 24 October 2024
Is your website helping or hurting your local business? In this post, we explore how a simple website redesign can make a big impact—boosting your brand's first impression, improving user experience, enhancing local search rankings, and driving more sales. Discover practical tips for optimizing your site to make it more user-friendly, mobile-ready, and effective at turning visitors into loyal customers. If your site could use a refresh, read on to learn how a few changes can make all the difference for your business growth!
Two men are sitting at a table looking at a laptop computer.
by Madison Mohn 15 October 2024
Small businesses need a website. We break down 8 reasons why small businesses need a website and provide solutions to get your business the website it needs.
Two women are sitting at a table looking at a laptop.
by Madison Mohn 26 September 2024
Learn how to optimize your web content for search engines while keeping it user-friendly. In this post, we’ll explore the key elements of effective SEO, focusing on creating a balanced approach that boosts visibility and engages readers without overloading your content with keywords.
A woman is sitting at a table using a laptop and a cell phone.
by Madison Mohn 11 September 2024
Learn how domains and hosting work, why they're essential for your website, and the importance of keeping your login information secure to avoid disruptions.
A man and a woman are sitting at a table with a laptop.
by Madison Mohn 26 August 2024
Thank you, Lancaster, for voting us the #1 Website Designer! We’re beyond grateful for your support and trust in our work. In our latest blog, we’re celebrating this amazing achievement and giving a special shoutout to some of our incredible clients who also took home top honors this year. From the best breakfast spot to top-notch pest control, these local businesses are truly the heart of our community. Check out the full blog to see the winners, and join us in celebrating Lancaster’s finest! 🚀
A picture of a mountain in the clouds with a keyboard in the foreground
by Madison Mohn 15 July 2024
Discover how Site Comments can transform your web development workflow. This powerful collaboration tool enables seamless communication between team members and clients, centralizing feedback and speeding up the review process. Say goodbye to scattered emails and phone calls – with Site Comments, you’ll enjoy faster go-live times, better client service, and more time to scale your business.
Two women are sitting at a table using a laptop and a cell phone.
by Madison Mohn 9 July 2024
Get found with Oostas social media marketing packages for small businesses. Schedule a consultation to get a custom proposal for your business and get started!
by Madison Mohn 22 May 2024
In the digital age, your website serves as the virtual face of your business. It’s often the first point of contact for potential customers, making it crucial for leaving a lasting impression.  Just like fashion trends change over time, website designs evolve too. So, how often should you refresh your website design to keep up with the times and maintain relevance in the ever-changing online landscape? Let’s explore.
More posts
Share by: